Alison rushes back to Rafe's Loft with the news that she just saw Joshua! Rafe immediately guesses that Elizabeth turned Joshua into one of the undead, rather than bumping him off entirely. Alison is surprised when Rafe explains that there was always the possibility that Elizabeth had turned Joshua rather than doing away with him entirely. Alison is happy when she realizes that, since Elizabeth did NOT actually kill Joshua, it would mean that Elizabeth has NOT crossed over to Caleb's world of eternally condemned souls. When Alison asks if Rafe would have had to eventually destroy Elizabeth if Elizabeth HAD crossed over, Rafe assures Alison that Rafe would have found ANOTHER way rather than destroy Alison's mother. Alison tries again to convince Rafe that Rafe should allow Tess to try to heal Caleb, but Rafe insists that Caleb has NO heart to heal and, while Rafe wishes that Tess COULD restore Caleb's soul, it is more likely that continued delay would only give Caleb more time to corrupt Tess the same way that Caleb corrupted Livvie. And, Rafe points out, Alison would ALSO become Caleb's target! But Alison affirms her belief that Rafe and Alison together are living proof that miracles DO happen!

Meanwhile, at Jack's River House, Jack asks Tess if the reason that he ALWAYS finds her with Caleb is because she is under some kind of spell. OR because she is NOT really happy with Jack - and really wants to be with Caleb instead. Tess assures Jack that she loves Jack only. But Jack reminds Tess that he has been through all of this before with Livvie. Tess argues that she only wants to HELP Caleb, because she was blessed with a gift and she MUST use that gift! Jack finally agrees that, if Tess truly believes that she CAN change Caleb, Jack will quit opposing her efforts and become supportive of Tess's mission to heal Caleb's heart. Tess assures Jack that he will NOT be sorry for having faith in her. Then Tess suggests that they go to bed. Jack told Tess to go ahead and get ready, but Jack needs to go out to pick up something special first. However, outside, Jack told himself: "I love you, Tess. I hope just one day, you will forgive me!"

At Stephen's Studio, Caleb demands to know what Joshua said to frighten Tess. When Joshua insists that he only tried to assure Tess that Joshua had misjudged her, Caleb guesses that Joshua has been turned in to a member of the Undead by Elizabeth. Joshua produces a knife and told Caleb to do whatever Caleb needs to do. But Caleb told Joshua that, when Caleb decides it IS time to be rid of Joshua permanently, Caleb will NOT need a prop! Caleb admits that he HAS missed Joshua's help in keeping the band in line. When Joshua told Caleb that "Newborn Heart" is a brilliant song, Caleb admits that he wrote the song so that Tess would believe that Caleb IS changing and Caleb could then succeed in luring Tess into trying to heal Caleb so that Caleb could draw Livvie out of Tess. Joshua congratulates his evil master for concocting such a brilliant plan. Caleb confesses that Caleb's orders to the big bat's follower's to take flight over Port Charles for a feeding frenzy was just an elaborate charade to convince Tess that she HAD changed Caleb and DOES have the power to 'uncover' the good in Caleb's heart. Joshua admits that Joshua would have gone ahead with the attack on the town. Joshua asks if Caleb is sure that Caleb still wants Livvie and NOT Tess. But Caleb insists that he wants only Olivia and NOT Tess - that Tess is merely a means to an end. When Joshua offers to help his master, Caleb reminds Joshua that Joshua is just an underling who can be easily exterminated. But, after Caleb leaves, Joshua gloats to himself that, by the time that Caleb discovers what Joshua is up to, it will be too late.

Meanwhile, back at Rafe's Loft, Rafe tries to explain to Alison that opposing evil forces is the only thing that Rafe has known all of his life. Rafe assures Alison that he appreciates her courage. But Alison admits that she has NOT been feeling very brave. Rafe confesses that he was scared every time that he was separated from Alison. Alison announces to Rafe that she has a perfect plan for getting revenge and begins lighting candles. Alison declares that, for a few hours, they will forget that Caleb Morley ever existed. Rafe and Alison soon hit the sheets. Afterward, Rafe gives Alison's engagement ring back to her and Alison gives Rafe's special watch back to Rafe.

Elizabeth slips into Stephen's Studio, looking for some more of Caleb's water, but finds only Joshua. Joshua informs Elizabeth that they are out of the special water and Joshua suggests that Elizabeth take care of her cravings with a 'traditional' feeding. Even though Elizabeth objects and Joshua admits that he is not really fond of Elizabeth either, Joshua soon bites Elizabeth.

Back at Rafe's Loft, while Rafe and Alison are making plans for their future, they are interrupted by a persistent knocking on their door. When Rafe answers the door, Jack bursts in and announces that he just set Tess up. Jack confides that Tess continues to believe that she can heal Caleb and Jack is afraid that Tess will never stop trying to 'heal' Caleb. So Jack pretended to Tess that he now supports Tess's mission to save Caleb. Jack warns Rafe and Alison that Caleb will destroy them all if they do NOT do something - soon! Jack then announces that Jack wants to be the one to drive the stake through Caleb's heart this time! Meanwhile, Tess is at the River House, lighting candles in anticipation of Jack's homecoming. But Caleb watches Tess from the porch and then materializes inside the living room and advances toward Tess.

At Ian's Loft, Lucy secretly makes plans to surprise Ian with a special treat called "The Taste of Ireland." However, a male stripper shows up and announces his plan is to step dance as he strips down to his Shamrock. Ian is amused as an embarrassed Lucy quickly pays the Dancer to leave before he strips down to his Lucky Charms. After the Dancer leaves, Ian gives Lucy a special gift of a four-leaf clover he found when he was a boy. Then Ian suggests that they go OUT for dinner!

At Stephen's Studio, Elizabeth coldly informs Joshua that the thought of satisfying her cravings with Joshua is too repulsive for her to even consider it. Joshua reminds Elizabeth that he is the only choice she has - unless she has a hidden lover somewhere. Mrs. Clay insists that her husband is her only passion but it is obvious that Caleb has moved on. Joshua brightens, as he observes: "So - I DID stir something in you, didn't I?"

ELIZABETH: "You certainly did! Utter disgust!"

Joshua reminds Elizabeth that Joshua plans to take Caleb's place and that Elizabeth has promised to help Joshua take Caleb down. But Elizabeth retorts that that does NOT mean that Elizabeth would allow their relationship to become anything other than a business arrangement. Joshua urges Elizabeth to just give in to her cravings but Elizabeth storms out of the room. After Elizabeth leaves, Joshua chuckles to himself as he assures himself that Elizabeth will come around eventually.

At Rafe's Loft, Rafe assures Jack that Lucy and Rafe will need to take care of eliminating Caleb. Alison objects to the possibility of Rafe and Lucy doing away with Caleb in front of Tess. Alison notices that Jack bought a replacement of Tess's doll for Tess's Valentine's Day gift and blasts Jack because it looks like Jack prefers to treat his new wife as a child! Alison points out that Jack wants the sweet, innocent, untouched side of Tess while Caleb wants the evil, manipulative side of Livvie - but what Livvie AND Tess both need is a chance to become one whole, complete, integrated person! Jack argues that Tess IS a complete person, just the way she is! When Alison appeals to Rafe for Rafe's opinion, Rafe replies: "I think, given the chance, Caleb is going to turn Tess into something we do not even recognize. And, if it were me, I would do anything to stop that!" Alison continues to warn Jack and Rafe that using Tess to get rid of Caleb could backfire and TESS could end up being the one who ends up VERY hurt by their plan!

Caleb calls Tess up to the Scenic Overlook that he introduced her to and plays "Newborn Heart" for her, claiming that he wrote the song just for her. Caleb informs Tess that he now believes that he is no longer destined to keep repeating the same mistake. Caleb kisses Tess and told her that it is because he is grateful to her for the new life she has opened up for him. Caleb then gives Tess a music box, claiming that Livvie was very fond of the music box and that the music from the box will bring Tess closer to Livvie. Tess prophesies that Caleb WILL love again, even though Caleb can NOT have Livvie! But, after Tess leaves, Caleb vows to himself: "Don't worry about me, Tess! I WILL find love again!"

Elizabeth arrives at Ian's Loft but arrives after Ian and Lucy have gone to dinner. Elizabeth lets herself in to wait for Ian and makes herself comfortable by stripping down to almost nothing. As she waits, Elizabeth spots Ian's research notes and reads: "Vampire symptoms are relieved when a vampire makes love with a slayer!" Elizabeth guesses that Ian is referring to his relationship with Lucy. Meanwhile, Lucy and Ian are enjoying dinner out when someone sends a complimentary bottle of wine to their table. When Lucy and Ian look around for their benefactor, they spot Kevin, who lifts his glass in salute! Meanwhile, back at Rafe's Loft, Rafe gives Alison some pink roses and they promise each other that they will forget about all of the evil lurking around Port Charles for a little while. They promise that they will always talk through their differences of opinion. Then they hit the sheets. At the same time, at the Scenic Overlook, Caleb affirms his belief that Livvie will find her way back to him, because Livvie has ALWAYS found her way back to Caleb. Meanwhile, Tess sets a romantic mood for Jack at the River House. But, as Tess writes a love letter for Jack, she opens Caleb's music box and begins to listen to the music and then begins to dance. By the time that Jack returns home, Tess has turned into Livvie!